
Perry angrily defends vaccination decision
Gov. Rick Perry today angrily defended his embattled order to vaccinate all Texas school girls against the virus that causes cervical cancer, saying it would have been irresponsible to ignore Merck & Co.'s ideas for requiring the shots statewide.
Perry said critics are getting lost on the campaign contributions, which he said were just a small share of the $24 million he raised and had no effect on his decision.
"When a company comes to me and says we have a cure for cancer, for me not to say, 'Please come into my office and let's hear your story for the people of the state of Texas, for young ladies who are dying of cancer,' would be the height of irresponsibility," Perry said. "Whether or not they contributed to my campaign, I would suggest to you, are some of those weeds that we are trying to cut our way through."
Pressed on when he decided to issue the executive order requiring the vaccination, Perry snapped: "I wish you all would quit splitting hairs, frankly, and get focused on are we going to be working together to find the cure for cancers. No, I can't tell you when."State Rep. Jodie Laubenberg, R-Rockwall, said Perry's staff failed him. "Whoever's setting up that meeting, they ought to be chewed out, you know, for not looking at everything and saying, 'Now wait a minute, could this cause any questions down the road?"
Merck has waged a behind-the-scenes lobbying campaign to get state legislatures to require 11- and 12-year-old girls to get the three-dose vaccine as a requirement for school attendance. But it announced Tuesday it was suspending those efforts.
The drug company had mainly funneled money through Women in Government, a bipartisan group of female state lawmakers. Many of the group's members have sponsored legislation in other states that would require the vaccine for schoolgirls.
One member of Women in Government is Texas state Rep. Dianne White Delisi, Deirdre Delisi's mother-in-law. Despite her ties to the group, the elder Delisi has opposed Perry's order and voted for the bill aimed at overriding it.
Perry spokesman Robert Black said the committee's vote doesn't change the governor's position. "He believes the state should do everything it can to protect young women from getting cancer," Black said. "He has encouraged the Legislature to have a vigorous debate on this issue. They are." Perry has said that cancer has touched several members of his family and that he is determined to use his authority to try and reduce the deadly disease. He also wants to sell the Texas Lottery to help fund anti-cancer efforts.
But the governor has alienated many social conservatives who have been key to his political fortunes with the requirement that pre-teens be inoculated against the most common sexually transmitted virus. Parents would be able to opt out their daughter
Pharmaceutical giant Merck abandoned its lobbying push to require girls to get vaccinations aimed at preventing cervical cancer, providing another possible setback to Gov. Rick Perry's plan to make Texas the first state to mandate the shots.Texas governor defends vaccine order
Saying the campaign was undermining its efforts to make the Gardasil vaccine accessible to as many women as possible, Merck officials announced they would no longer try to convince states that the vaccine should be made mandatory for preteen girls to attend school."Maybe we'll get even some more with Merck acknowledging that this isn't the right thing to be doing right now," said Rep. Dennis Bonnen, R-Angleton, who introduced HB 1098, which could be voted out of the Public Health Committee as early as today.
Bonnen said Merck had gotten ''extraordinary publicity for free" about its vaccine as lawmakers debated the issue.
''Maybe they felt they had hit the point of diminishing returns," Bonnen said.
Merck's stock closed Tuesday at $44.50 a share, slightly below its level before Perry's executive order.
Rep. Jessica Farrar, D-Houston, who has filed a bill to make the HPV shots a requirement, said that people opposed to requiring any vaccines for school admission and social conservatives "have hijacked the issues" surrounding Gardasil, which protects against four strains of HPV that can cause 70 percent of cervical cancers.
"Without any real evidence, they are trying to distort the science and cause confusion and distrust," Farrar said.
Merck officials said they remain convinced of Gardasil's effectiveness and the company will continue its efforts to make it widely available.
In the past month, there's been a definite "uptick" in the use of the vaccine, according to Merck spokesman Chris Loder.
Critics have previously questioned Perry's ties to Merck. Mike Toomey, Perry's former chief of staff, now lobbies for the drug company. And the governor accepted a total of $6,000 from Merck during his re-election campaign.Time line of events involving the HPV vaccine in Texas
Merck has waged a behind-the-scenes lobbying campaign to get state legislatures to require girls to get the three-dose vaccine to enroll in school. But on Tuesday the pharmaceutical company announced it was suspending the effort because of pressure from parents and medical groups.
The Kentucky House on Thurday passed a bill that would require the vaccination for middle school girls unless their parents sign a form opposing it. The state has the nation's second-highest death rate from cervical cancer, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention; the bill still needs Senate approval. Virginia lawmakers have also passed legislation requiring the vaccine, but the governor has not decided if he will sign it.
Aug. 15: Two Perry staffers meet with a Merck lobbyist for an "HPV Vaccine update," documents obtained by The Associated Press show. Deirdre Delisi, Perry's chief of staff, has lunch with another Merck lobbyist, Mike Toomey, her predecessor in the governor's office. Perry spokesman Robert Black said he didnot know what they discussed.
Nov. 7: Perry is re-elected with 39 percent of the vote.
I just could not pass this date up either, Mr. Plurality decides to act as if he is Ronald Reagan in 1984.
AUSTIN, Texas — Gov. Rick Perry's chief of staff met with key aides about a new vaccine to prevent cervical cancer on the same day its manufacturer donated money to his campaign, documents obtained by The Associated Press show.
Texas became the first state to require the vaccine against human papillomavirus earlier this month when Perry issued an executive order requiring it for girls entering sixth grade. Lawmakers are considering overriding the measure.
A calendar for chief of staff Deirdre Delisi obtained under Texas' open records laws shows she met with the governor's budget director and three members of his office for an "HPV Vaccine for Children Briefing" on Oct. 16. That same day, Merck & Co.'s political action committee donated $5,000 to Perry and a total of $5,000 to eight state lawmakers.
I want to see who the 8 state lawmakers are as well and see how they vote on this issue.
HPV vaccine's cost turning into key issue
AUSTIN — The high cost of the vaccine that protects against a sexually transmitted virus linked to cervical cancer is becoming a key issue in opposition to Gov. Rick Perry's order that schoolgirls receive the shots.Vaccine plan puts Perry on new stage
The Texas Medical Association opposes the mandatory use of the human papillomavirus vaccine partly because of it's effect on doctors' finances. Perry's mandate has the potential to increase doctor's revenue — which will be taxed by the state for the first time next year — but not necessarily their profit, said TMA spokesman Brent Annear.
AUSTIN — What has gotten into Gov. Rick Perry?
That question has been echoing around Austin since the governor, much to every one's surprise, "ordered" the vaccinations of schoolgirls against a sexually transmitted virus linked to cervical cancer.
This, after all, is the Rick Perry who has so closely courted religious and social conservatives that his pronouncements sometimes sounded more like those of a fundamentalist minister than the governor of a major state.He is the Rick Perry who, according to popular speculation, wants to use that conservative support to become a player on the national political stage.
On track to become the longest-serving governor in Texas history, he surely wants to be remembered for more than building toll roads and raising college tuition, two of his more noteworthy accomplishments so far.
Maybe he would rather be remembered as the governor who launched an all-out attack on cancer.
But the governor also has personal motivations. His wife, Anita, a former nurse, is said to be strongly supportive of the vaccine order. His father-in-law is a retired doctor, and the Perrys, like most Texans, know people whose lives have been ravaged by cancer.
The governor may harbor dreams about being the vice presidential nominee on the 2008 Republican ticket, although his top political strategist denies it. Perry fanned the speculation with several references to international problems during his inaugural speech last month.
Actually the headlines say enough... but here is something for you to chew on.
AUSTIN - Gov. Rick Perry's effort to get young girls vaccinated against a sexually transmitted virus linked to cervical cancer drew praise Thursday from two prominent Democrats, former Gov. Mark White and former Attorney General Jim
Mattox.
White, who was attorney general for four years before being elected governor in 1982, declined to comment on the legality of Perry's executive order, deferring to the current attorney general, Greg Abbott, who has been asked by two lawmakers to rule on the issue.
"I applaud him (Perry) for the courage he had in issuing the order," said White, who recently underwent surgery in Houston for removal of a cancerous kidney. "It's wise for our state officials to be mindful of medical advances."
"I happen to believe that the governor who sold the lottery plan to benefit education, Ann Richards, would look with pride upon us for what we are doing to find a cancer cure that's out there in the future," he said.
But Mattox said he thinks Perry was "usurping the Legislature's authority to make statutory and funding decisions. To that extent, he's probably stepped beyond his authority."
Buck Wood, an Austin lawyer and veteran litigator of Texas constitutional issues, agreed with Mattox that Perry had exceeded his authority.
Gov. Rick Perry is right to push for all Texas girls to be vaccinated against a virus that causes cervical cancer.
Normally I'm suspicious of anything a politician does that will make billions of dollars for a company that hired his former aide as a lobbyist.
But I got over it after talking to the woman who sat next to me during the fourth quarter at a friend's house.
She's not a fan of Perry nor of the big drug companies. She is, however, a great fan of women with cervical cancer and has spent decades researching the disease and treating its victims at one of Houston's great hospitals.
In some developing countries, she said, cervical cancer is a leading killer of women, even more common than breast cancer. It is very common in Latin America, which is relevant to Texas because of immigration patterns.
She also agrees with Perry that vaccination should be universal, though his
executive order does provide for parents to opt out.
"The goal should be to eliminate the virus," she said. "And we only do that if everyone gets the vaccination."
In fact, she favors vaccinating boys as well, although she knows that the cost of the vaccine may be prohibitive.
Perry refused to rescind the executive order he issued Friday requiring the vaccine for girls ages 11 and 12 who are entering sixth grade in September 2008. Parents will be able to opt out their daughters, as they can for other required vaccines.
In a statement, Perry addressed criticism that the vaccine could send a message that teenage sex is permissible."This needs closer examination. How much will it cost the state?" asked Sen. Jane Nelson, chairwoman of the Senate Health and Human Services Committee, at a press conference. "Most importantly, as a mother of four daughters, I want to make sure our daughters' health is protected and parental rights are preserved."
Nelson, R-Lewisville, asked Perry to reverse his order and said she also would ask the attorney general whether the Legislature has any recourse if he doesn't.Also, a spokesman indicated that first lady Anita Perry's strong support for the vaccine may have played a role in the governor's decision. A former nurse and the daughter of a doctor, Anita Perry works for an organization
dealing with sexual assaults. "I know they have discussed it, and it's something they both feel very strongly about," said Press Secretary Robert Black.His former chief of staff, Mike Toomey, is a lobbyist for Merck and Perry has received $6,000 in contributions from the drug manufacturer's political action committee since 2005.
Black said Perry and Toomey have never discussed the issue, and he noted the campaign contributions to Perry from Merck were relatively small. He said Perry indicated his support for the vaccine during the recent reelection campaign.Austin political consultant Bill Miller said he thinks Texans are seeing a governor showing some independence after winning a hard-fought campaign over three rivals for his second full term. Perry took office in 2001 when George W. Bush became president. "This is an example of the governor going his own way without political consequences. He has immunity at the ballot box," Miller said.